Limited Weekend Update – Star Trek Red Alert! The Red Shirts Are Winning
This weekly article will keep you up to date on the current state of Limited on MTG Arena. Thfor week, we're examining the data at the Star Trek MTG set.
Hey everyone! Welcome back to another edition of Limited Weekend Update, where we take a perfectly reasonable hobby and turn it into an excuse to spend several hours staring at spreadsheets before I babble about what I found.
I know some of you probably thought LWU had been canceled, and God only knows why it hasn’t. But let’s be honest here: did I really need to squeeze another one of these in while I was already pumping out a ridiculous number of Limited articles in such a short amount of time?
Anyway, back to actual Limited talk.
Star Trek has finally landed, and we’ve had enough time to start getting a pretty good picture of the format. More importantly, we’ve had just enough time for everyone to confidently declare that they’ve completely solved it before changing their minds three days later.
Naturally, I’m going to contribute to that problem.
As always, we’re not simply going to look at which cards and archetypes have the highest win rates. The important thing is figuring out why they’re performing that way and what we can actually learn from those numbers.
Because if your entire draft strategy consists of sorting 17Lands by win rate and blindly taking the highest card, you’re probably going to have a bad time.
So, let’s see what the numbers have to say.
For clarity, everything we’re examining comes directly from 17Lands Premier Draft data as of Sunday morning, November 15, 2026.
The format-speed data now includes more than 170,000 games, while our two-color archetype table includes 88,462 games.
That gives us a pretty substantial amount of information to work with, even if we’re still in the opening stages of the format.
The overall win rate for the two-color decks in our sample is 55.3%.
Remember, 17Lands users generally win more frequently than the average Arena player. That means a 53% win rate isn’t necessarily a sign that a particular archetype is performing well.
We need to evaluate these results relative to the other decks being played by the same population.
I’m also going to look at Improvement in Hand (IIH), which compares a card’s win rate when it appears in your hand with its win rate when it stays unseen in your deck. It isn’t a perfect measurement, and we shouldn’t treat it as a magical number that tells us exactly how good a card is.
But when we combine it with Games in Hand Win Rate (GIH WR), Average Taken At (ATA), and an understanding of how the cards actually function, we can start identifying some pretty interesting things.
The numbers tell us what’s happening.
Understanding why it’s happening is what helps us become better players.
Let’s start with the ten two-color combinations and see what it tells us about the individual colors.
Color Pair
Win Rate
Gruul (RG)
58.3%
Rakdos (BR)
58.0%
Golgari (BG)
57.6%
Boros (RW)
56.7%
Izzet (UR)
55.9%
Simic (GU)
54.6%
Selesnya (GW)
53.2%
Orzhov (WB)
53.2%
Azorius (WU)
52.8%
Dimir (UB)
49.3%
Well, that’s interesting. Apparently, all those red shirts we expected to get killed immediately have decided to start winning instead.
The first thing that jumps out is that red appears in four of the five strongest color combinations. That’s an awfully impressive performance for a single color.
What’s particularly interesting is that red isn’t succeeding with just one specific strategy. Gruul is focused on landfall. Rakdos wants to attack with Klingons. Boros cares about reaching eight power, and Izzet is doing its usual spellslinger nonsense.
Four different strategies, all performing above the format average. That suggests red has a particularly strong foundation of cards rather than one specific broken archetype carrying the entire color.
Green is doing pretty well for itself too, occupying two of the top three spots.
Meanwhile, Dimir is apparently experiencing the Kobayashi Maru scenario, except nobody has figured out how to cheat the simulation.
Top of the Class: Gruul, Rakdos, Golgari
Gruul
Gruul currently leads the format at 58.3%, and I can’t say I’m particularly surprised to see it doing well.
The strategy is about as straightforward as they come. Play lands. Trigger landfall. Turn creatures sideways. Occasionally, play another land and turn even larger creatures sideways.
What makes the strategy particularly appealing is that it doesn’t need to assemble an elaborate combination of cards to function. You were planning to play lands anyway. Getting additional value from something your deck already wants to do is an excellent starting point.
Gruul also benefits from having some very strong commons in both colors, which helps explain why it’s performing consistently. You don’t need to open a ridiculous rare or mythic to build a competitive deck. That’s a pretty significant advantage in Limited.
Rakdos
Rakdos comes in second at 58.0%.
Apparently, the Klingons have decided that diplomacy is overrated. Who could have seen that coming?
The aggressive strategy is clearly working, but the important thing is that the deck isn’t sacrificing much card quality to support it. Red provides efficient creatures and removal, while black offers additional interaction and ways to generate value through sacrifice.
The Klingon synergies certainly help, but you don’t need to assemble the entire High Council before you can start doing something useful. The deck can simply play good creatures, remove opposing blockers, and keep attacking. That’s been a classic plan for Rakdos success in many past limited formats.
One important thing to keep in mind is that aggressive decks tend to have an advantage early in a format while everyone is still figuring out what actually works.
While people are busy experimenting with elaborate synergies and questionable build-arounds, the aggressive decks are perfectly happy to play efficient creatures, turn them sideways, and punish anyone whose deck isn’t functioning properly.
The question is whether that advantage will hold up as the format develops. Will Gruul and Rakdos continue dominating, or will their win rates start to come back down to earth as players figure out how to build and pilot the other archetypes more effectively?
That’s going to be one of the more interesting things to watch over the next couple of weeks.
Golgari
Golgari rounds out the top tier at 57.6%.
This is by far the most interesting of the three to me because it’s doing something a little different. Instead of focusing exclusively on applying pressure, Golgari is looking to generate additional value from the graveyard.
What makes Golgari successful appears to be that its graveyard synergies are attached to cards that are already useful. You’re developing the battlefield while stocking your graveyard and recovering resources. You aren’t simply spending your first several turns accomplishing nothing while hoping your elaborate engine eventually comes together.
And as we’ll see when we examine the individual cards, green has some absolutely excellent commons supporting that game plan.
Middle Tier: Boros, Izzet, Simic
Boros and Izzet are both performing above the overall average, sitting at 56.7% and 55.9%, respectively. Those are both perfectly respectable numbers, and I wouldn’t hesitate to draft either one if the cards were flowing.
Boros
Boros benefits from the same strong red cards that are helping Gruul and Rakdos succeed with a bunch of aggressive white creatures thrown in. I would say that the thing that holds it back is that a few too many of the white commons are designed for certain archetypes rather than being able to fit into a generic aggressive deck.
The eight-power threshold isn’t particularly difficult to reach when you have several creatures on the battlefield and access to power-boosting effects. The question is how often your cards remain effective when you can’t reach that threshold. So far the response is still coming in above average and that’s not bad.
I don’t really need to spend more time on this because it’s Boros. IYKYK.
Izzet
Izzet is apparently required by federal law to be a spells deck in every Limited format. I’m pretty sure Wizards has a special department dedicated to ensuring this never changes.
What makes this version a little different is that there are so many noncreature artifacts that can trigger many of the spellslinger payoffs. That provides considerably more flexibility than a traditional spells deck where you’re sometimes forced to play every questionable instant and sorcery you can find.
I’m also hesitant to make any definitive judgments about Izzet this early. Spells decks can take longer to figure out because players need to identify the correct mixture of creatures, spells, and payoffs. Sequencing matters more, and it’s particularly easy to build a pile of cards that technically support the same strategy without actually functioning together.
I’m interested in seeing whether Izzet improves once people gain more experience with the format.
Simic
Simic is sitting at 54.6%, slightly below the overall average, so you’re probably wondering how it managed to sneak into this tier.
Simply put, I’m not treating this as a traditional Simic deck. I’m looking at it as a Strange New Worlds deck, since that’s the archetype it’s designed to support. Simic wants to splash into other colors and take advantage of some pretty sweet payoffs.
And decks like that are always going to produce some really sus statistics, especially this early in a format.
Some drafts, you simply won’t get there with your mana base. Other times, someone is taking all your payoffs despite only playing two colors, leaving you with a beautiful collection of fixing and absolutely nothing worth casting.
This also isn’t quite the same as building a traditional five-color soup deck, where you grab every fixing land and ridiculous bomb you see. A lot of the Star Trek bombs are highly archetype-dependent, so you can’t necessarily throw together a pile of individually powerful cards and expect everything to work.
On top of that, these decks are difficult to draft, build, and pilot properly. That’s especially true during the first few weeks of a format, when people are taking wild swings just to see what they can get away with.
So while the early numbers aren’t particularly impressive, I’m not ready to judge the archetype based on them. There’s a lot more going on here than the 54.6% win rate suggests, and I suspect we’ll get a much clearer picture once people figure out how to build these decks consistently.
Sad Trombone Tier: Selesnya, Orzhov, Azorius, Dimir
And now we get to the decks that haven’t been enjoying the first few days quite as much.
Selesnya, Orzhov, and Azorius are all performing below the overall average, but none of them are so terrible that you should automatically avoid them.
I’m not going to go too in-depth on each one because they all fall into roughly the same category: potentially excellent decks, provided you’re not fighting the table for the cards you need.
And that’s something I really want to emphasize.
Finding the open lane is considerably more important than blindly forcing whichever archetype happens to have the highest win rate.
A wide-open Selesnya deck can be considerably stronger than a mediocre Gruul deck you forced because a spreadsheet told you it was the best archetype. The numbers tell you which strategies are performing well on average. They don’t tell you what cards the other seven people at your table are passing. Draft the deck that’s actually available to you, not the one you wish you were drafting.
Selesnya’s counters strategy can produce some absolutely ridiculous creatures when everything comes together. The problem is that you need the right combination of creatures and counter generators to make that happen.
Orzhov’s Borg strategy has a similar issue. The artifact synergies offer some powerful possibilities, but the deck needs the appropriate pieces before those interactions become worthwhile.
Azorius has some excellent Spacecraft payoffs, but stationing those ships requires resources that aren’t necessarily contributing to your immediate battlefield development.
All three decks appear to be suffering from some degree of inconsistency. There’s a meaningful difference between a deck that functions naturally and one that needs several specific cards before it starts doing something impressive. That’s why being able to recognize what the right pieces are and when they are flowing is going to win you a lot more drafts than fighting over Red.
And then there’s Dimir. Sigh…
49.3%.
Wow…that is certainly something..
That’s six percentage points below the average for two-color decks.
The Dilemma strategy was always going to require some setup. You’re playing modal spells, trying to generate additional value from those choices, and occasionally getting rewarded for jumping through hoops that other decks simply don’t have.
Unfortunately, the early results suggest those rewards aren’t consistently making up for the investment. Why spend several cards assembling an engine when another deck can produce comparable value simply by playing efficient creatures and removal?
I will give Dimir this much credit here. Any deck built around making decisions is naturally going to struggle more in the hands of average and below-average players. And this entire archetype is built around making decisions.
It starts during the draft, where you have to figure out which modal spells are actually worth playing and which ones are terrible Magic cards that happen to Face a Dilemma.
Then you’ve got the decisions during the games themselves. Which mode do you choose? When do you cast your spells? How do you sequence everything to maximize your payoffs? Are you getting enough value to justify all the hoops you’re jumping through?
Those decisions add up, and making the wrong ones can turn an already complicated strategy into a complete disaster.
That’s also why I’m hesitant to write Dimir off entirely. A difficult archetype can look considerably worse in the overall data than it actually is when drafted and piloted properly.
Of course, there’s also the possibility that we’re all putting way too much effort into making a fundamentally mediocre strategy work.
Now this is where things get particularly interesting.
One of my favorite things about Reality Fracture was how much time it gave players to actually play Magic.
It was a relatively slow format, and the extra time meant that players had more opportunities to make meaningful decisions rather than simply getting run over before their decks could do anything interesting.
Well, apparently Starfleet has decided we’re operating on a much tighter schedule.
Here are the current Premier Draft numbers from 17Lands.
Format
Average Turns
Reality Fracture
9.848
Alchemy Reality Fracture
9.443
Marvel Super Heroes
9.002
Star Trek
8.648
The Hobbit
8.609
That’s a pretty substantial difference.
Star Trek is averaging 8.648 turns per game, compared to 9.848 turns in Reality Fracture.
We’re talking about a difference of 1.2 turns per game.
That might not sound particularly significant, but in Limited, an additional turn can completely change which cards and strategies are viable.
A six-mana creature that provides incremental value over several turns becomes much more appealing when you regularly have time to take advantage of it. A card that requires several turns of setup becomes considerably less exciting when your opponent is already threatening lethal damage before the engine is operational.
And Star Trek isn’t just slightly faster than Reality Fracture. It’s essentially operating at the same speed as The Hobbit. That’s not exactly the comparison I was hoping to make because the general consensus was that people hated that limited format.
Now, I don’t want to suggest that slower decks are automatically unplayable. Golgari’s success clearly demonstrates otherwise. But that raises another interesting question: Is Golgari particularly well-positioned to prey on all these aggressive red decks?
There’s an old Constructed adage that midrange beats aggro, control beats midrange, and aggro beats control. Obviously, that’s an oversimplification, and Limited doesn’t follow those rules nearly as neatly, but the basic principle is still worth considering.
With so many aggressive decks running around, Golgari might be benefiting from being exactly the kind of deck that can punish them. Efficient creatures, solid removal, and incremental value are pretty good tools for dealing with opponents whose entire game plan revolves around killing you before you get comfortable.
And that brings us to an important distinction.
There’s an enormous difference between a slower deck that plays efficient creatures while generating incremental advantages and one that needs several turns to assemble the pieces necessary to start doing anything impressive.
Golgari is doing the former, while some of the lower-performing archetypes are doing the latter.
One can spend the early turns interacting with the opponent while gradually pulling ahead. The other is busy assembling its elaborate plan while a Gruul player is enthusiastically turning creatures sideways and wondering why the game isn’t over yet.
Being slower isn’t necessarily the problem. The problem is spending too much time doing nothing in a format that doesn’t give you that luxury.
And unfortunately, the news doesn’t get much better here.
The current win rate on the play is 54.3%.
For comparison:
Format
Win Rate on Play
Reality Fracture
52.4%
Alchemy Reality Fracture
52.5%
Marvel Super Heroes
52.6%
Star Trek
54.3%
The Hobbit
54.6%
Well, crap.
I was really hoping we were going to see something closer to Reality Fracture. That format’s relatively low play advantage was one of the things I enjoyed most about it.
The difference between 52.4% and 54.3% might not look enormous at first glance, but we’re talking about thousands and thousands of games. That’s a pretty substantial shift toward rewarding the player who wins the opening coin flip.
And when we combine that with the shorter average game length, it starts painting a fairly consistent picture. Star Trek appears to reward efficient early development considerably more than Reality Fracture did. That’s not inherently a bad thing. There’s plenty of skill involved in drafting and piloting aggressive decks.
But it does mean that players who enjoy slower, more methodical games may not find this format quite as appealing. I certainly prefer having more opportunities to make meaningful decisions rather than spending half my games desperately trying to stabilize after losing the coin flip. Unfortunately, the numbers suggest we’re going to be doing considerably more of that.
But before I start wrapping things up, I want to touch on a few cards that have already generated plenty of screenshots in my inbox.
That’s right, we’re talking about alternative win conditions.
The biggest one I missed on, and one that will definitely be featured in next week’s article, is Ensign Pavel Chekov.
In my original review, I said that milling someone out with Chekov was going to be difficult. What I completely overlooked was how easily you could accomplish that with one of the set’s mechanics, Beam Me Up.
Chekov is a legitimate win condition that can steal games you otherwise have absolutely no business winning. I underestimated him, and I’ll give him the attention he deserves next week.
I know exactly where everyone’s mind went with this one. We’re bringing back the glory days of Illusions of Grandeur and Donate, and yes, I’ve already seen plenty of screenshots showing that the combo works.
I’m still declaring this one a meme.
You’re playing two otherwise bad cards in the hope that you’ll draw both, successfully assemble the combo, and somehow avoid having your plans disrupted along the way.
Can it work? Absolutely.
Is it a good game plan? Not particularly.
But I fully expect people to keep doing it because there’s apparently no greater satisfaction in Magic than winning a game in the most unnecessarily complicated way possible.
Now, this one is interesting because I haven’t actually received a screenshot of someone winning with it yet. I’m positive it’s happened somewhere, and I’m equally positive that whoever pulled it off immediately took a screenshot to prove it.
I’m also declaring this one a meme.
I’m not saying you can’t win with it. I’m saying that building your deck around making it happen is probably a considerably worse strategy than simply trying to win a normal game of Magic.
Of course, that has never stopped Magic players before, and I certainly don’t expect it to start now.
This is where the relationship between archetype data, individual card performance, and format speed becomes particularly useful.
The weaker strategies appear to have more cards that require substantial setup before providing an adequate return. Meanwhile, the stronger decks are filled with creatures and removal spells that generate value or tempo without asking for much in return.
That’s probably not a coincidence.
And before anyone starts sharpening their pitchforks, that doesn’t mean synergy is bad.
Golgari is doing extremely well, and that’s certainly a synergy-driven strategy. The important distinction is that its individual cards are useful even when you aren’t assembling some elaborate combination.
Temporal Conqueror is a perfectly reasonable Magic card on its own. It’s almost guaranteed to replace itself while providing a body that conveniently dodges multiple removal spells and puts the brakes on opposing 2/2s.
Hologram Stalker generates a tremendous amount of value immediately, with the potential to keep the party going. It conveniently combos with the aforementioned Temporal Conqueror taking it from good to amazing.
You aren’t being forced to choose between executing your strategy and putting good cards into your deck.
There’s another important distinction here: neither of those cards are rares.
That consistency across drafts is an enormous advantage. You can start building a functional deck around commons and uncommons without praying that the right rares get opened or that the person passing to you suddenly develops an irrational hatred of good Magic cards.
A huge takeaway from the first week of Star Trek is that the format rewards efficient cards that contribute immediately while generating additional value. That’s particularly important when games are ending before turn nine.
Red has an excellent collection of commons and uncommons that allow its decks to maintain pressure without sacrificing card quality.
Green has some outstanding supporting cards that work across multiple strategies.
And some of the more complicated archetypes are struggling to generate enough value to justify all the work they’re asking you to do.
The format-speed data reinforces that conclusion. At an average of 8.648 turns per game, we’re operating in an environment much closer to The Hobbit than Reality Fracture.
That makes tempo, early development, and efficient interaction particularly important. You can certainly build toward something powerful in the late game, but you need to actually survive long enough to get there.
Another major lesson is that we need to distinguish between good cards and cards being played in good decks.
Planetary Patrol is a perfect example. Its overall win rate is extremely impressive, but its Improvement in Hand is basically nothing.
That doesn’t make it a bad card. It means the decks playing it are successful, and Planetary Patrol is helping those decks execute their plans without necessarily being the reason they’re winning. It’s filling out the curve, contributing to the board, and doing its job without requiring much of an investment.
Not every card needs to be the star of the show. Sometimes being a reliable supporting actor is exactly what a deck needs.
And perhaps most importantly, we need to pay attention to when cards are actually being drafted.
Finding strong playables several picks later than they’re worth can provide a significant advantage over the course of a draft.
At 68.2% GIH and +15.1 percentage points IIH, the data certainly agrees.
But figuring out that you’re getting cards like Cantankerous Captain around your eighth pick while they’re contributing to some of the strongest strategies in the format?
That’s information you can actually use.
The goal isn’t to look at the highest win-rate cards and congratulate ourselves for discovering that bombs are good.
It’s to find the cards everyone else is undervaluing, understand why they’re performing well, and take advantage of that information before the rest of the table catches on.
Because finding a great card in your opening pack is nice.
Getting one when everyone else has already passed on it is considerably better.
Do you hate Universes Beyond as much as the rest of us do? The Star Trek set is really turning me off. – Corky T
First off, Randy’s attempts to get me to talk more about the Sizzler have been denied.
Second, I’m absolutely not repeating the comparison Corky made to describe just how much the Star Trek set was turning him off.
Corky, buddy, I say this with genuine concern: you might want to consider therapy. Whatever you’ve got going on there is probably a little above the pay grade of a Magic: The Gathering columnist.
I guess I’m going to answer a controversial question that’s guaranteed to upset a large portion of my audience no matter which way I answer.
At least it’s not about Alchemy. That might wipe out my entire “fan” base.
Here’s the thing about Universes Beyond: I honestly don’t care one way or the other, as long as it provides a good experience playing the game I love.
Would it be nice if they stuck to properties that fit naturally into the Magic multiverse? Sure.
Lord of the Rings and Final Fantasy were perfect examples. They brought a ton of new players into Magic who might never have given the game a chance otherwise, and the numbers suggest that plenty of them stuck around.
That’s a great thing for the long-term health of the game, whether you personally enjoy Universes Beyond or not.
Now, I’ll admit that Star Trek is a little further out there, but we literally had a space-based Magic set with Edge of Eternities last year. Are we really going to pretend that spaceships are suddenly some enormous leap?
And honestly, slapping an actor’s face onto a card isn’t fundamentally that different from putting some random fictional legendary character on a card in a traditional Magic set.
Either way, we’re playing a game where imaginary characters fight imaginary characters by casting imaginary spells. I’m not particularly concerned about whether one of them happens to be played by Patrick Stewart.
Of course, that brings us to the elephant in the room.
How the hell am I supposed to justify Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles?
Well, we’re dealing with a multiverse here. And if there’s one thing I’ve learned about multiverses, it’s that they’re bound to have a few OMFGWTF moments scattered around.
Sometimes you planeswalk into a world filled with powerful wizards, ancient dragons, and terrifying demons.
Other times, you end up in a sewer with four mutated turtles who have an unhealthy obsession with pizza.
That’s just the risk you take when traveling between dimensions.
TL;DR: If it’s good Magic, that’s what really matters to me. I’m far more concerned about whether a set is fun to draft than whether its characters belong in the traditional Magic universe.
We’re only a few days into Star Trek, and the format is already giving us plenty to discuss.
Red is off to an absolutely spectacular start, green has some excellent supporting cards, and several overlooked commons are performing considerably better than their draft positions might suggest.
Meanwhile, some of the more elaborate strategies are struggling to get their engines running.
And now that we’ve got the format-speed numbers, we’ve got a much better understanding of why that might be happening.
The big question is how much of this will survive once the format evolves.
Will Gruul and Rakdos continue dominating, or will the slower decks figure out how to fight back?
Will Dimir find a way to make its Dilemma strategy work, or is that archetype destined to spend the entire format looking like it failed the Kobayashi Maru?
And perhaps most importantly, how many more cards from my set review are going to make me look like an idiot?
We’ll find out.
I’ll be back with another edition of Midweek Magic and more Limited Weekend Update, where we’ll see how the format develops and whether any of these early conclusions survive contact with reality.
Thanks for reading!
Until then, stay classy people.
Premium
Enjoy our content? Wish to support our work? Join our Premium community, get access to exclusive content, remove all advertisements, and more!
No ads: Browse the entire website ad-free, both display and video.
Exclusive Content: Instant access to all exclusive articles only for Premium members, at your fingertips.
Support: All your contributions get directly reinvested into the website to increase your viewing experience!
Discord: Join our Discord server, claim your Premium role and gain access to exclusive channels where you can learn in real time!
Special offer: For a limited time, use coupon code L95WR9JOWV to get 50% off the Annual plan!
Josh is a member of the elite limited team The Draft Lab as well as the host of The Draft Lab Podcast. He was qualifying for Pro Tours, Nationals, and Worlds literally before some of you were born. After a Magic hiatus to play poker and go to medical school, he has been dominating Arena with over an 80% win percentage in Bo3 as well as making #1 rank in Mythic.